Advanced Care Planning: Ethical Considerations

September 14, 2023
Dr. Cathy Maxwell
Dr. Cathy Maxwell
United Kingdom
Ethics in Healthcare
Dr. Cathy Maxwell, a distinguished scholar with a Ph.D. in Nursing Ethics from the University of Oxford, is committed to fostering ethical excellence in healthcare. She has a rich academic background.

In the dynamic field of healthcare, nurses play a crucial role in ensuring that patients receive the best possible care. One vital aspect of nursing practice is Advanced Care Planning (ACP), which involves making important decisions regarding a patient's future healthcare preferences. ACP is not only a clinical responsibility but also a topic that students often encounter when doing their nursing assignments. In this blog, we will delve into the ethical considerations surrounding Advanced Care Planning and discuss how students can approach assignments related to this topic.

Understanding Advanced Care Planning (ACP)

Before delving into the ethical aspects, it's important to grasp the essence of Advanced Care Planning. ACP is a process that involves open and ongoing communication between healthcare professionals, patients, and their families to discuss the patient's values, goals, and healthcare preferences. This helps in making informed decisions about the patient's care, especially when they are unable to express their wishes themselves.

Ethical Considerations in Advanced Care Planning

Ethical considerations in Advanced Care Planning (ACP) encompass ensuring patient autonomy by respecting their preferences and values, while also navigating potential conflicts between beneficence and non-maleficence in making life-sustaining treatment decisions. It is essential to address issues of justice, such as equitable access to ACP resources, and to acknowledge the diverse cultural and legal factors that shape ACP discussions and decisions. Balancing these ethical principles is paramount to providing patient-centered and ethically sound ACP in healthcare practice.

1. Autonomy and Informed Consent: One of the fundamental ethical principles in healthcare is autonomy, which emphasizes an individual's right to make their own decisions. In ACP, patients are encouraged to express their preferences for future care, ensuring their autonomy is respected. Nurses must ensure that patients are well-informed about their options and that their decisions are made voluntarily without any coercion.

2. Beneficence and Non-Maleficence: These ethical principles dictate that healthcare professionals should act in the best interests of the patient and avoid causing harm. In ACP, nurses must balance the benefits of certain interventions with the potential harm they may cause, especially when patients are faced with complex decisions regarding life-sustaining treatments.

3. Justice: The principle of justice emphasizes fairness in the distribution of healthcare resources. In the context of ACP, nurses should ensure that decisions regarding future care are made without discrimination or bias, considering all relevant factors.

Approaching Nursing Assignments on ACP

Now that we've explored the ethical considerations surrounding ACP, let's discuss how students can effectively complete their nursing assignments related to this topic:

1. Understanding the Basics:

    • Begin by thoroughly comprehending the core concepts of ACP. This involves understanding the purpose of ACP, which is to facilitate communication between patients, families, and healthcare providers regarding future healthcare decisions.

    • Familiarize yourself with the steps involved in the ACP process. These typically include initiating conversations about healthcare preferences, documenting decisions in advance directives, revisiting and updating plans as needed, and ensuring the appropriate dissemination of ACP documents.

    • Identify the key stakeholders involved in ACP, including the patient, their family members, nurses, physicians, and legal professionals.

    • Explore the legal aspects surrounding ACP, such as the requirements for creating valid advance directives and the role of healthcare proxies or power of attorney in decision-making.

2. Research Ethical Guidelines:

    • Delve deep into ethical guidelines and principles that govern ACP. This includes exploring the principles of autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice, which underpin ethical decision-making in healthcare.

    • Refer to reputable nursing associations and organizations like the American Nurses Association (ANA) and their Code of Ethics for Nurses. These sources provide valuable insights into ethical considerations specific to nursing practice and ACP.

    • Analyze how these ethical principles apply to real-world ACP scenarios and decisions. Consider the ethical implications of honouring a patient's wishes versus the obligation to provide necessary medical interventions.

3. Incorporate Real-Life Scenarios:

    • To deepen your understanding and engage your readers, incorporate real-life scenarios into your assignments. These could be case studies or examples that showcase the ethical dilemmas and challenges that can arise during ACP.

    • Analyze these scenarios from various ethical perspectives. Consider how different ethical principles might guide healthcare professionals in making decisions, and explore the potential conflicts that may arise when these principles intersect.

4. Legal and Cultural Factors:

    • Acknowledge the influence of legal and cultural factors on ACP decisions. Different countries and regions may have distinct laws and cultural beliefs that impact the ACP process.

    • Discuss how variations in legal frameworks and cultural norms can affect the way ACP conversations are initiated, the acceptance of advance directives, and the role of family members in decision-making.

5. Engage in Critical Thinking:

    • Encourage critical thinking in your assignments by examining the ethical implications of various ACP decisions. Pose questions that challenge students to think deeply about the consequences of their choices in hypothetical scenarios.

    • Encourage students to provide well-structured arguments supported by ethical principles. For instance, they can explore how the principle of autonomy might clash with the principle of beneficence in certain ACP situations.

6. Interview Healthcare Professionals:

    • If possible, conduct interviews with healthcare professionals, particularly nurses, who have practical experience with ACP. Their insights can provide valuable practical perspectives for your assignment and offer real-world examples of ethical challenges they've encountered in ACP.

7. Referencing:

    • Ensure that your assignments are well-referenced and properly cite ethical frameworks, guidelines, and scholarly articles related to ACP ethics. Robust referencing enhances the credibility of your work and demonstrates thorough research.

8. Peer Review:

    • Before submitting assignments, encourage students to seek peer review. Constructive feedback from peers can help refine arguments, improve clarity in writing, and identify any ethical considerations that may have been overlooked.

By following these steps, nursing students can approach assignments on Advanced Care Planning with a strong foundation in ethical principles, practical insights, and a comprehensive understanding of the ACP process. This not only enhances their academic performance but also prepares them for the ethical complexities they may encounter in their future nursing careers.


Advanced Care Planning is a critical aspect of nursing practice, and understanding its ethical considerations is essential for nursing students. When approaching assignments related to ACP, remember to delve into the ethical principles, consider real-life scenarios, and engage in critical thinking. By doing so, you'll not only excel in your assignments but also contribute to the ethical practice of nursing, ensuring that patients' wishes are respected and their best interests are served.

No comments yet be the first one to post a comment!
Post a comment